Buyer Beware Of Fakes

These items have been sold at Auctions and Auction websites.  They should be considered reproductions and/or fakes.  The cannonballs listed are either 12-pounder shot putts, bearings, or rock crusher balls from a rock quarry.  None of the items on this page are original Civil War period.  If you have a fake and want it listed here please email jack@jwmelton.com with a photograph. 

American Thunder Antiquities 4-F List Of Civil War Fakes
http://www.rulen.com/4f/

Gary Williams Fake Buckle Website
http://www.civilwarfakes.com

Civil War Fakes, Frauds, & Fantasies by "The Dogpile"
http://www.shotwellsantiques.com/cgi-bin/information_view.asp?45

Civil War Relic Man:
http://www.relicman.com/reproduction.htm

Frohne's Historic Military
http://www.modoc1873.com/exofebfak.html

North South Trader's Civil War magazine with a couple of fake resources:
http://www.nstcivilwar.com/cgi-bin/display_Items.asp?Cat=18

Here are links to sites that sell reproduction Bowies and knives.  These are sold as reproductions but somehow end up being faked.

Atlanta Cutlery
http://www.atlantacutlery.com/webstore/eCat/swords_and_knives/history_makers/bowies.aspx

Crazy Cow
http://www.crazycrow.com/

Please visit http://www.hanoverbrass.com for a wonderful selection of 1st generation copies of the originals sold as reproductions.  Often these buckles are made into fakes by other people due to their high quality.

Back to Main Page

ALL OF THE BELOW ITEMS ARE 100% FAKE

11starfrontplate.jpg (147181 bytes)
11starbackplate.jpg (116719 bytes)

la2piece.jpg (55280 bytes)
7thcavplate.jpg (74357 bytes)
csabugleplate.jpg (78252 bytes)



7thmiss1.jpg (165019 bytes)
7thmiss.jpg (165630 bytes)
alabamaplate.jpg (90636 bytes)

csaplate.jpg (78486 bytes)

csclipcorner.jpg (87099 bytes)

csaguplate.jpg (65815 bytes)
martingaleplate.jpg (56603 bytes)
fortwagnerbuckle.jpg (75981 bytes)

missplate.jpg (80143 bytes)

gabuckle.jpg (91313 bytes)

csastockadebuckle.jpg (100197 bytes)
csastockadebuckleback.jpg (97616 bytes)
slavetag100.jpg (74634 bytes) slavetage.jpg (57178 bytes) slavetaglaborer.jpg (63460 bytes)
laswordplate.jpg (87812 bytes) slavetagedward.jpg (71867 bytes)
csplatecrude.jpg (56607 bytes)
slavetagplantation.jpg (55167 bytes)
 
nc2piece.jpg (50100 bytes)
nc2pieceback.jpg (81412 bytes)
ordandhatplate.jpg (41038 bytes) texas.jpg (65061 bytes)
slavetageporter.jpg (34839 bytes)
swordplatefront.jpg (86520 bytes)
swordplateback.jpg (82452 bytes)
slavetagplantation.jpg (55167 bytes) slavetagsc.jpg (69684 bytes) slavetagva.jpg (58038 bytes)
slavetagplantation2.jpg (82792 bytes) 12shotput.jpg (48298 bytes) cannonball-3.jpg (72596 bytes) largecannon.jpg (352258 bytes)













 






Not American
Civil War used.

 



Fake
C.S.A. 1862
Selma Arsenal
2nd Arkansas
Regiment.
Leather sides & strap.



 
RING GAUGE: A flat iron ring with a wooden handle, used to determine the diameter of a spherical projectile. The gauge came in two sizes; the largest 0.02- or 0.03-inches greater than the true diameter of the projectile; the smallest 0.02- or 0.03-inches or less than the true diameter. To be a true diameter, the projectile should not pass through the small gauge at all but had to pass in any direction through the large gauge.  Ring gauges are always flat and have precise tooling.  Here is an example of what is sold today as ring gauges but in fact are not ring gauges nor do the have anything to do with artillery.  The US Navy stamp was applied by an unscrupulous person that owns the real stamp.

Fake Ring Gauge

Fantasy Fuze Wrench
Fantasy Fuze Wrench